top of page
Writer's pictureDrew Porter

The Irony: Andy Reid Will Get Kyle Shanahan Fired Because He "Can't Win The Big One"


A Tale of Two Coaches

In the high-stakes world of the NFL, the narrative can be as ruthless as it is ironic. The upcoming Super Bowl has set the stage for a dramatic storyline featuring Kansas City Chiefs' Andy Reid and San Francisco 49ers' Kyle Shanahan. Once in the same boat, Reid has managed to steer away from the dreaded label of “can't win the big one,” a tag that's now threatening to anchor Shanahan’s career.


Reid's Redemption - The Turning Point

Remember when Andy Reid was the guy who couldn't clinch the big wins? His early 2000s tenure with the Philadelphia Eagles was marked by this narrative. But fast forward to his time with the Chiefs, and the picture changes dramatically. Reid's journey to Super Bowl glory has been a testament to perseverance and adaptation. He evolved from the coach who “couldn't win the big one” to a Super Bowl champion, redefining his legacy in the process.


Shanahan's Rising Pressure - A Familiar Echo

Kyle Shanahan, a brilliant offensive mind, is now where Reid once was. Despite leading the 49ers to impressive regular-season performances and playoff runs, he’s yet to secure that elusive Super Bowl victory. His journey, marked by Super Bowl heartbreaks with both the Falcons and the 49ers, seems to echo Reid’s past. As NBC Sports Bay Area analyst Donte Whitner pointed out, Shanahan had his best coaching year in 2024, yet the ultimate test still awaits.


The Crux of the Irony

Here's where the irony bites hard: Andy Reid, once haunted by the very narrative that's now latching onto Shanahan, could be the one to cement it. If the Chiefs emerge victorious in the upcoming Super Bowl, Shanahan’s career could take a hit, pushing the narrative of him being unable to win “the big one.” This scenario isn't just speculation; it's a reflection of the NFL's harsh reality, where past failures, however narrow or circumstantial, can define a coach's legacy.


The Brutal Truth of NFL Coaching

This isn't just about Shanahan or Reid. It's about the cutthroat nature of NFL coaching. Jason Fitz and Frank Schwab from Yahoo Sports discussed how playoff failures could significantly alter the perception of a coach like Shanahan, moving from “unbelievably great” to a coach burdened by playoff failures. The same was said about Reid until he shattered that narrative with the Chiefs.


The Unfair Game of Legacy

NFL coaching is as much about legacy as it is about strategy. The unfairness in judging a coach's entire career based on a few key games is evident. Yet, it's the game they play. For Shanahan, the upcoming Super Bowl is more than just a game; it's a battle against a narrative that's been years in the making. A narrative that Reid knows all too well.


The Final Whistle

As we gear up for this epic showdown, the stakes are high, and the narratives are compelling. For Andy Reid, it’s about cementing his legacy further. For Kyle Shanahan, it’s about breaking free from a narrative that threatens to define his career. The irony is palpable: Reid’s victory could potentially set Shanahan on a path that Reid himself once walked. In the NFL, the storylines are as gripping as the games themselves, and this one is no exception.

1 view0 comments

Comments


bottom of page